Auto Insurance
Insurer Says the Accident Was Your Fault? Dispute It
✓ AppealIQ cites your state's specific claims-handling law where available.
They said denied. You say appeal. Paste your auto insurance denial or bill into the free analyzer — see why you were denied and how to fight it.
Analyze my denial — freeFault determinations drive everything in an auto claim — whose insurer pays, your premiums, and any injury recovery. Adjusters allocate fault from a file, quickly, and their allocation is not final: it's an evidence-based conclusion you can challenge with better evidence.
Most states use comparative negligence, so fault is allocated in percentages — shifting the split even 20 points can change the outcome materially, and in modified-comparative states it can flip recovery on or off entirely.
The evidence hierarchy
Start with the police report: the narrative, diagram, cited violations, and witness statements. If it contains factual errors, request a supplement or amendment from the reporting agency. Physical evidence often decides close cases — damage locations and crush patterns, skid marks, debris fields, and increasingly dash-cam or nearby surveillance footage, which should be requested fast before it's overwritten.
Traffic law matters: a citation issued to the other driver for the movement that caused the crash (failure to yield, following too closely, unsafe lane change) is strong evidence of negligence. Quote the statute.
Writing the fault rebuttal
Ask the insurer for its fault allocation and the evidence behind it, then rebut item by item: what the report actually says, what the physical evidence shows, what witnesses observed, and how your state's comparative-negligence rule applies to those facts. Demand a re-evaluation with a written, itemized basis for whatever allocation results.
Set a 15-business-day deadline and name the escalation: Department of Insurance complaint, and where the insurer's own insured's version is contradicted by physical evidence, note that continued reliance on it isn't a reasonable investigation.
Not sure why you were denied?
Paste your auto insurance denial or bill into the free Denial Analyzer — the reason in plain English, your appeal angle, and the laws that apply. No signup.
Analyze my denial — freeFrequently asked questions
Is the police report final on fault?
No — it's persuasive evidence, not a verdict, and reports with factual errors can be supplemented. Insurers and courts weigh it alongside physical evidence, witness statements, and traffic law.
Can I recover if I was partly at fault?
In most states, yes — comparative negligence reduces recovery by your fault percentage. Modified-comparative states cut off recovery at 50% or 51%, which is why disputing even part of an allocation matters.
They said denied. You say appeal.
A complete, citation-backed appeal letter with your facts and your state's law — ready to send. Pay once, no subscription.
Get my appeal letter → $19Not sure yet? Analyze your denial free first · file often? unlimited plans
This page is general information, not legal advice. AppealIQ is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice. Deadlines and rules vary by state and plan — verify yours before acting.